When Cyborg started asking the elves where the naughty list was, the elf beside Cyborg told him to be quiet or else they would get in trouble. Cyborg didn't listen, and when he decided to continue talking in a vociferous manner, the Chief Toy Maker bursted out of his office. Making his way to where Cyborg was standing and then making piercing, direct eye contact, Cyborg (because of his nerves) blamed his fellow elf worker for blabbing. The Chief Toy Maker, fed up with all the noise, called Jingle and Jangle, and they unjustly took the poor, innocent elf away.
Like most of his species, the Chief Elf is rather short and has pointed ears. Except for tiny tufts of red hair, he is mainly bald, but tries to cover this fact with a light green golf cap with a bow design. His clothing consists of red overalls and a pale green undershirt with a white collar and gilded buttons. The Chief Elf Toy Maker is very distinct in that he wears spectacles and has a large, bushy mustache.
- The True Meaning of Christmas (debut)